Well, it’s enough to make you swear.
Yesterday, 28th Feb 2024, the State of Texas executed a man called Ivan Cantu by lethal injection; perhaps you’ve heard of his case, perhaps not. Why am I mentioning him on a blog demonstrating Ramirez’s unfair trial? Because of reasonable doubt. Reasonable fucking doubt.
Taken at face value, the cases are very different; Cantu was convicted of the double murder of his cousin, James Mosqueda and his fiancée, Amy Kitchen, in Dallas in 2000. Richard Ramirez was convicted of serial murder and rape. The similarities between them lie in their defence rather than their alleged crimes; both were Hispanic, neither was given due process and the right to a fair trial, and each of them received the death penalty.
Like Ramirez before him, Cantu was saddled with a lawyer who did not bring forward defence witnesses, a lawyer who failed to investigate the charges against him or develop a defence strategy. No expert defence witnesses were brought in to testify. Star witnesses for the prosecution committed perjury, and the jury was not given exculpatory evidence to consider.
There is a podcast dedicated to Cantu’s case, “Cousins by Blood”, created by Private Investigator Matt Duff (I will link it at the end). So, I need not go over the highly complicated case, but I urge you to listen to it as he brings forward the evidence omitted in court.
In this podcast, the star witness recants and admits he and his sister (Ivan’s ex-girlfriend) lied to the police and in court. The lead detective deliberately hid exculpatory evidence, evidence which has now come to light. That’s a Brady violation, yet this detective said he didn’t even know what “Brady” means. He doesn’t know. If I know, why doesn’t he? The clothes Ivan was supposed to have worn that night did not show any of his DNA and were much too large for him. The jury foreman has spoken out, saying they were not given all the evidence to deliberate. He requested the document they had to sign, saying they agreed with the punishment, to be returned to him; he has changed his mind, as have others. The list goes on.
Ivan’s case garnered support from celebrities like Kim Kardashian, Martin Sheen and Susan Sarandon. Over 140,000 signatures were collected on a petition sent to Collin County Court. Nothing worked. Ivan was merely asking for his right to a fair trial; he was not begging for his life. He wanted justice and was given none, in the same way Ramirez was denied it.
We are taught to put our trust in the law and in justice, and today, I have seen people genuinely shocked about Ivan Cantu’s execution, as if they had never considered that justice is not what it seems. The 6th Amendment tells us that every accused man must have fair representation, but just because the person standing up with a defendant is a lawyer, that’s not enough to satisfy the Constitution; the lawyer is required to defend. So why does this keep happening?
For a country that vigorously defends the 2nd Amendment, America doesn’t seem so bothered about the 6th.
Yesterday, I read comments from someone who had practised law for 16 years. Their opinion (I will paraphrase) was that the Public Defenders are there mainly to drive a plea bargain, not to defend. It’s ticking boxes, not delivering justice. Richard Ramirez was correct in his assessment of that.
Some people think we’re here crying about “innocence”; we are not. We are here to show how badly a case was handled from start to finish; we are explaining that there was a case for reasonable doubt. If “innocence” is what you see when reading what we’ve said, rather than whine about it on TikTok or attack people who support us, ask yourself why. (Hybristophilia is not a good look, by the way).
Meanwhile, the Ramirez case is still used for fame and money, using the tragic events as entertainment. It really is enough to make you swear.
My sympathy goes out to all the victims in these cases, the ones who don’t get justice and to the accused, who are not allowed to defend themselves when reasonable doubt exists.
LISTEN TO THE “COUSINS BY BLOOD” PODCAST HERE
Leave a comment